Maia Papaya Brings in the Spring 2010
Tatiana and her huge wiggly tongue

Disney, daddies, and dumb decisions

by Tatiana on July 6, 2009

When I was 17 years old, I ran away from home.

It was the summer before my senior year of high school.  I bought a bus ticket to Michigan, where “the man of my dreams” — we’ll call him Leon — lived.  We had met online several months earlier, and he had come out to visit me in Connecticut for Christmas and New Year’s Eve.  We didn’t get to spend New Year’s Eve together; I spent the transition from 1999 to 2000 in my bedroom, grounded and furious.  Leon’s the person who bought me the Hot Damn that I got drunk off for my 17th birthday.

What he hadn’t told me, and what I discovered soon after arriving in Michigan, is that he, at 24, lived in his parent’s basement.  He also hadn’t told his parents that I was visiting, never mind planning to move in.  This was not the first of his deceptions, and certainly not the last.

tatiana&dadMy dad and I

As I’ve written before, if I have any “relationship” with my father at all, it’s a frail, tempestuous one.  And while I take personal responsibility for my actions, I also can’t deny that I — that any person — is shaped by their life experiences, and that includes what he’s done to me.  So when I say that I felt adrift, confused, and completely abandoned by him, and when I say that those feelings are part of what contributed to me seeking out some man to love me, some man to fill that void in my heart left by him, I know that I have every right to it.  And Leon happened to be the first man that came along.

However, something else contributed to me seeking out a man to save me: Disney. I grew up in the Golden Age of Disney movies, when they were all still musicals featuring beautiful, spirited princesses who somehow nonetheless were incomplete until they found their man.  I remember seeing The Little Mermaid in the theatres with my mom, and both of us crying at the end when Ariel gets married, hugs her father, and whispers, “I love you, Daddy“.  I remember watching Belle finding true love as she kissed The Beast.  I remember Jasmine crying out, “I am not a prize to be won!” and then, dressed in fiery red scraps, being rescued from the evil Jafar by a daring Aladdin.

I grew up — so many women grow up — with the concept that someday my prince will come and rescue me pounded into their heads.  This isn’t even a subtle message.  It’s the plot line of our youth.  I just looked through this list of Disney animated movies and the number of them I loved where that storyline is implemented is staggering.  There is no denying that I believed my prince was out there, searching for me as I searched for him.

Again, let me say that I take responsibility for what I did.  I’m not writing that I ran away because of my father and Disney, but I am writing that having those two influences in my life has shaped me as a person.  The person, the teenager, I was, was not a wise enough girl to look inside herself, find the strength nurtured by all the positive influences on her life, and abandon the idea that she needed to be rescued.

Now, as a mother, clearly I worry about my daughter.  I look at her in Chris’ arms and think, “You are the first man she’s in love with. Don’t break her heart.“  I hold her in my own arms, nursing her, our bodies two separate entities now and yet still so completely dependent on each other, and think, “Make your own mistakes. Don’t make mine.“  She will make mistakes.  She will have her heart broken.  She will break mine.  But I can’t stomach the thought of her doing the same things I did.  When I imagine her being as weak as I was, nausea rises in my throat.  I think of someone treating her the way Leon treated me and a primal, irrational fury consumes me, the need to protect her burning so strongly at the very core of my being that I would face anything, anything, to keep her from that anguish.

rapunzel2 by dina goldsteinSo when I saw this feature in JPG Magazine called “Fallen Princesses”, where a photographer took the stories of Cinderella, Snow White, Belle, Sleeping Beauty, Jasmine, Rapunzel, and Little Red Riding Hood, then looked at them in a modern, post-fairy tale light, it really resonated with me. Now that I’m more than a decade removed from Disney’s target audience, and I’ve come into my own, I look at those images and nod.

Cinderella in a bar, despondent, staring at a shot glass and being eyed askance by a pair of rough-and-tumble men, the type you expect to see hanging out in a place like that during the day.

Snow White, barefoot and surrounded by her own little dwarves, her mask of resignation unable to hide the desperate look in her eyes that cries, “Yes, this is my fairy tale ending — is it yours?”

Belle, lying with eyes closed, hands clasped, on a surgery table, bloody stitches crowning her hairline, a needle penetrating her grotesque lips and a scalpel carving her face.

On and on.

Yet at the end of Disney movies comes a happily ever after, doesn’t it?

When you find your prince, you find meaning in life, don’t you?

It’d be nice if those things were true.  They aren’t.  I thought they were.  I made ignorant decisions and I hurt my family.  I did these things because I genuinely believed that love conquers all, that love is easy and, if I just pursued my prince, everything else in my life would fall into place.  I don’t want to tell Maia she can’t watch Disney movies.  I love the thought of her dressing up as a princess and inventing her own fairy tales.

I just hope she comes to understand that there’s a reason they’re called “fairy tales” sooner than I did.

{ 25 comments… read them below or add one }

becky 07.06.09 at 12:26

I’ve never read something so honest. I really wish that I had the courage to write something like this. <33

Maria 07.06.09 at 14:16

Stunning.

Thank you for writing this.

nic @mybottlesup 07.06.09 at 14:20

brilliant and beautiful.

Sugar Jones 07.06.09 at 14:22

It’s so true that, although we are responsible for our own actions, our daddy’s shaped who we became as women. I had two poor excuses for fathers, both with their own demons to battle. One, alcoholism. The other, depression. Thanks mom! It’s no wonder we escaped into a fantasy world.

Thanks for your honesty and openness!

Miss Grace 07.06.09 at 14:24

This post is staggeringly beautiful.

Loukia 07.06.09 at 14:25

Very touching, very real, very well-written post. Thank you for this!

Parent Club 07.06.09 at 14:26

One of the BEST posts I have ever read! Your honesty is inspirational

Maya 07.06.09 at 14:27

What a beautiful post.
It’s true, our daughters first loves are their fathers. I know mine was, and he disappointed me in more ways than I know.

I saw this shoot a few weeks ago and thought it was beautiful. I esp loved Snow White. Isn’t that how we all end up?

(your daughter has a beautiful name- wink wink)

Lisa 07.06.09 at 14:33

Wow, absolutely beautiful and raw.

PS. My daughter’s name is Maya too :)

abbie 07.06.09 at 14:33

Wow. That made me cry. I can relate to this on every level. It’s like you were telling my life story.

Thank you.

andrea's sweet life 07.06.09 at 14:34

What a wonderfully thoughtful post. Have you ever seen the movie Enchanted? It deals with these same issues in a lighthearted way.

andrea's sweet life 07.06.09 at 14:36

What a wonderfully thoughtful post. As the mother of two daughters, who made more than her fair share of stupid mistakes, this really resonates with me!
Have you ever seen the movie Enchanted? It deals with these same issues in a lighthearted way.

MG @ MommyGeekology 07.06.09 at 14:37

A perfect post. My daughter is three, she loves princesses. Everything is related to princesses for her.

I have the same hope – I hope she can learn to take it with a grain of salt, because we don’t all need that dream. We don’t all want it, and we don’t all get it.

Pamela 07.06.09 at 14:39

beautiful. just beautiful. i love your honesty

Alicia 07.06.09 at 14:44

WOW, great post, and great links to JPG MAG.

Thanks for sharing!

Gala 07.06.09 at 15:44

Having a mom and dad that are still married (50years now), it is impossible to understand what you have gone through, though watching you go through it was the hardest thing that I have ever done. My heart ached so much for you, as I knew you were struggling to be LOVED by a man at a young age. I could love you, your uncle/grandfather, etc. could love you, but it doesn’t replace the dad for some women.
My dad made his share of mistakes while I was growing up, and I ended up in some relationships I never should have been in, just to try to make him happy. I was basically told not to “waste” my time going on to college because I would just end up getting married and having babies anyway. So…that is what I did. Though I don’t regret it simply because the result was three wonderful children, I wish my father hadn’t always put my dreams down.
I wish fathers and fathers-to-be would read post such as this, and realize just how important action and in-action are.

Michelle 07.06.09 at 16:29

Wonderfully, wonderfully written. The things we know now… In fact, I still catch myself dreaming of the fairy tale. *sigh* :)

Katie 07.06.09 at 23:27

Ohhh Disney. This has been the subject of more than just one essay in my college career. There was a whole course at Eastern taught by one of the best prof’s I had that was entirely surrounding debunking the Disney myths. “The Lion That Roared” even looked into it, and was a fantastic source for the papers that all the students wrote that ripped into a Disney tale and extracted it’s actual being.–The story it was supposed to be, Hansel and Gretle with a mother and father, fewer evil stepmothers, and actual real-life answers. It’s in Maia’s blood to be a reader, and I just hope she’ll be able to easy see the difference that Disney makes between movies, stories, and real life.

Jinxy 07.07.09 at 00:31

I had a great reply written up but it took 4.5 hours to get Lily down for the night so now my brain is mush, sorry.

This is a wonderfully honest, open, heart wrenching post.

Maggie May 07.07.09 at 00:45

this is a kick ass post that resonates with me.

Jen LF 07.07.09 at 10:00

This is a great post. Many aspects of it resonate with me. I’m terrified of what Disney might do to my daughter – the focus on the princesses has evolved considerably since I was a little girl. Thank you for writing it!

Tatiana 07.07.09 at 10:18

Thank you all for your comments and support. It’s really interesting to me that I’ve tapped into an apparently touchy, but perhaps under-discussed, topic. If you enjoyed this post, you may want to drop by Maria’s post about strong mothers and their presence, or lack thereof, in children’s movies: Courage of the Heart: http://www.mommymelee.com/2009/07/courage-of-heart.html

cristin 07.11.09 at 18:38

I love this post… I read it last week but didn’t have a chance to comment (I was reading blogs at work… bad Iknow…)

I too was convinced I needed to find someone to take care of me and protect me… to save me… I didn’t even know I didn’t need saving…

Rebecca @ Playground Confidential 08.06.09 at 14:18

What a lovely, well thought out and emotionally honest post. I have always resisted the princess impulse — even as a child. (Though I do have a few years on you.) And of all the insidious marketing directed at our children the Disney Princesses irk me more than anything. I can deal with sex and violence. Hell, I can deal with body issues and materialism. But how do you deal with the deep-set message that a knight in shining armour will whisk you away to a happy ending?

“I look at her in Chris’ arms and think, “You are the first man she’s in love with. Don’t break her heart.“”
Amen.

Steve 08.06.09 at 16:10

Lovely article. I don’t have any children yet, but I’m looking forward to being the best Dad I can be. I don’t have any illusions it’s going to be easy and there will be tantrums and tears but I hope that I’m always the one man my daughter (If that’s what my girlfriend and I have) can always rely on :)

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Previous post:

Next post: